THE EFFECT OF BIRTH BALL USE ON LABOR
PROGRESS: A LITERATURE REVIEW
Harwin
Holilah Desyanti, Shofiatul Widad
Fakultas Kesehatan Universitas Nurul Jadid, Jawa
Timur, Indonesia
Email: harwinkd.ub@gmail.com, shofiawidad4@gmail.com
Keywords: Pregnancy;
Birth Ball; Length of Labor. |
ABSTRACT The problem of the high number of MMR and IMR in
Indonesia is that there are still many prolonged labor which is one of the
several causes of maternal and newborn mortality. One of the therapies that
can be done to prevent this is the use of Birth balls. Birth balls can
prevent maternal fatigue caused by long duration of labor. The purpose of
this articel was to provide an overview of the effect of birth ball exercises
on the progress of the first stage of labor. This research used the
Literature Review method. The sampling method used purposive sampling
technique by selecting articles with appropriate topics. The results of the
study through the stages of identification, screening, eligibility and
include, found that there was an effect of giving birth ball exercises
therapy in accelerating the progress of labor in maternity mothers. This is
because the birth ball exercise is able to relieve pressure and increase the
area of the pelvis, encourage the baby's head to descend, help uterine
contractions more effectively, accelerate cervical dilation, and help to
relax the ligaments in the pelvis. |
Info
Artikel |
Artikel masuk 28 January 2023, Direvisi 31
January 2023, Diterima 07 February 2023 |
Introduction
According to the World Health Organization (WHO) report,
maternal deaths generally occur due to complications during, and after
pregnancy. The types of complications that cause the majority of maternal death
cases, about 75% of the total maternal death cases, are bleeding, infection,
high blood pressure during pregnancy, labor complications, and unsafe abortion.
One of the complications of labor that contributes to maternal mortality is
prolonged partusm(PERTASARI,
2022).
The high maternal
mortality rate (MMR) in Indonesia due to childbirth ranks 3rd highest in ASEAN
after Laos and Myanmar. One of the factors affecting labor is power. If the
power weakens, it will save the labor process (Anuhgera,
Ritonga, Sitorus, & Simarmata, 2021). Problems in Indonesia itself are
still found including prolonged partus which is one of several causes of
maternal and newborn deaths.
Prolonged parturition is
one of the causes of maternal mortality. However, the number is not as much as
bleeding and hypertension. Still, if not treated immediately or prevented
beforehand, it will cause complications and emergencies for both the mother and
the baby. Long partuses can cause bleeding, shock, and death in the mother and
can cause fetal distress, asphyxia, and caput (Wigati
& Mualimah, 2021). Factors that can affect the length
of labor are: maternal characteristics, body mass index, maternal age, parity, oxytocin
administration, epidural analgesics (Mutoharoh,
Indrayani, & Kusumastuti, 2020). Meanwhile, another factor that
affects the length of labor is the state of the pelvis. Pelvic deformities can
hinder the labor process. Fetal location and presentation are an important part
of the labor process (Wigati
& Mualimah, 2021).
The Birth Ball is a
physical therapy ball that assists labor and can be used in various positions,
namely sitting on the ball and wiggling the pelvis, which is thought to provide
comfort and speed up labor time. Using the Birth Ball during pregnancy stimulates
postural reflexes and maintains the muscles that support the spine. Pelvic
Rocking can also be done by rocking the pelvis back and forth. Pelvic rocking
exercises can train the waist and buttock muscles and help lower the baby's
head into the pelvic cavity of the birth canal. (Junaida, et al. 2021).
The active phase becomes
shorter with the use of birth balls, which can prevent fatigue in laboring
mothers caused by the long duration of labor. Fatigue during childbirth which
includes physical and mental discomfort during labor can be prevented as much
as possible because fatigue in labor can cause delays in cervical dilatation or
complications in the first stage of the active phase (Salamah & Putri,
2022). The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists in Artal (2003)
mentions in the journal Umi Salamah and Alfi Aulia (2022) the conditions of
laboring mothers who are not recommended to exercise are mothers who give birth
with liver disease or lung disease, incompetent cervix, multiple pregnancies,
premature birth, antepartum bleeding, premature rupture of membranes, mothers
with hypertension and decreased fetal movement.
The purpose of writing
this literature review is to review several journals that we used as literature
in writing this journal so as to evaluate the effectiveness and benefits of
using birth balls to progress opening during labor.
Methods
The purpose of this
review is to further examine the effects of birth ball use on pregnant women in
labor. This study is a literature review study that tries to explore more
information about the effects of birth ball use on pregnant women in labor.
Sources for conducting this literature review included a systematic search of
computerized databases including Google Scholar, Pubmed, Sciencedirect, IJSR,
Research Gate and IJWHR. The search used the keywords pregnancy, birth ball and
labor. Research journals were used from 2017 to 2022. The studies were analyzed
according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria.
Researcher and Year |
Methods and Procedures |
Results |
(Mu’alimah & Wigati, 2022) |
1.
Method: Quasi-experiment research with
posttest control design 2.
Samples: 32 respondents with a population
of all mothers with a gestational age of 36-40 weeks 3.
Procedure: Physical movement patterned with pelvic rocking |
Result: the mean value of the length of labor
time when I was between the treatment group was 7.2500 and the control group
10.1562. The value of P-value = 0.0000 < the value of α 0.05, which
means that there is a difference in the length of the delivery time of the
first stage labor in the treatment and control groups. |
(Fahlevie, Anggraini, & Yunola, 2022) |
1.
Method: Pre-experimental analytical
research with an Intact-Group Comparison design 2.
Samples: 30 respondents, there were
15 (50%) women who gave birth who became the treatment group using Birth Ball
and there were 15 people (50%) of women who became the control group. 3.
Procedure: The respondent sat on the ball
when he entered the first stage of the active phase with back and forth
movements, left and right side then rotated clockwise. |
Result: p-value = 0.002 < 0.05, which means that there is an
effectiveness of Birth Ball on the duration of the 1st active phase of
primigravida. |
Umi Salamah, Alfi Aulia Putri (2022) |
1.
Method: Analytic research with cross
sectional design 2.
Samples:113 3.
Procedure: pelvic rocking technique |
Result: From the results of statistical
tests there is avalue of p = 0.04 = 0.05 so that there is a relationship
between the use of a gym ball on the length of the first stage of labor prove
that there is an effect of using a gymball on the progress of labor in the
active phase I inpartum mother. |
Alexandre Delgadoa, Tuíra Maiaa,
Renato S. Meloa, Andrea Lemos (2019) |
1.
Method: Systemaic Rewiew for all randomized
clinical trials (RCTs) or quasi-randomized 2.
Samples: 7 studies included 3.
Procedure: Studies that used the birth ball
during the first and/or second stage of labor as an intervention compared to
a control group or usual care that did not included the birth ball use. Types
of Birth Balls: Swiss Ball and Peanut Ball. Studies that compared the birth
ball to pharmacological methods of pain control were excluded |
Result: Results shows that the use of birth
balls compared with usual hospital care during labor can reduce pain after 20
to 90 minutes by 1.46 and 1.95 points in Visual Analogic Scales, based in a
moderated quality of evidence. |
(Shirazi, Kohan, Firoozehchian, & Ebrahimi,
2019) |
1.
Method: Randomized clinical trial. 2.
Samples: 178 participants including 89
women in each group. The inclusion criteria included having a tendency for
participation, being in 30-32 weeks of gestation, having a normal pregnancy,
and having no history of a disease or obstetric complications based on a
standard prenatal chart. 3.
Procedure: The women in the intervention group
were asked to join a planned exercise with the birth ball including a 20-minute
well-defined exercise three times a week for 6–8 weeks at home whereas those
in the control group followed up the routine prenatal cares. |
Result: Based on the results, birth ball
exercises could significantly improve childbirth self-efficacy and pain so
that labour pain was lower in this group of women as compared to the other
group (P<0.001 in both cervical dilatations). In addition, the score of
selfefficacy was higher in the intervention group compared to the control
group (P<0.001).. |
Yeung, May Pui Shan, et al (2019) |
1.
Method: Prospective multi-centre randomised controlled trial (RCT) 2.
Samples: The
target population is Chinese women with an uncomplicated singleton pregnancy
at gestational age of 37 to 42 weeks. Participants are randomised based on parity
(nulliparous and multiparous) and type of labour onset (spontaneous and
induced). 3.
Procedure: Women in the intervention group are
actively offered and taught how to use a birth ball; those in the control
group receive the usual midwifery care. |
Result: Intention-to-treat analysis is
adopted and performed by researchers masked to subjects’ group allocation. A
two-sided P value of 0.05 or less is considered statistically significant.
The effect of using the birth ball on pain intensity, satisfaction with pain
relief and childbirth experience, and sense of control in labour.. |
The results of the research obtained by the researcher after conducting
the literature stage of identification, screening and critical appraisal
feasibility test, 6 journals were obtained that had suitability, namely
discussing the effect of birth ball exercises therapy on the length of labor in
laboring mothers in Stage I. Stage I labor is a period of labor characterized
by the discharge of mucus mixed with blood (bloody show) because the cervix
begins to open (dilatation) and flatten (effacement). Stage 1 is divided into
two parts, namely the latent phase and the active phase. The latent phase is
the initial phase of cervical opening when the opening is 1-3 cm. In contrast,
the most extensive cervical dilation occurs in the active phase, and the
presenting part of the fetus descends further into the pelvis. In primiparous,
women are expected to experience dilation of at least 1 cm / hour and
multiparous mothers 1.5 cm / hour (Mu’alimah & Wigati, 2022).
The maternal mortality rate to date
(in 2022) has reached 207 per 100,000 KH, which is above the Renstra target of
190 per 100,000 KH (Situbondo Health Office, 2022). Meanwhile, in 2021, the
Ministry of Health (Kemenkes) noted that 7,389 mothers in Indonesia died in
2021. This number increased by 59.69% compared to the previous year, which was
4,627 people with the highest cause being Covid-19, namely 2,982 people and as
many as 1,320 mothers died from bleeding last year (Andini, 2020).
The
first journal (Mu’alimah et al., 2022), research was conducted with the
pelvic rocking technique where the technique is a way to accelerate the labor
process, namely by moving the pelvis in the direction of rotation during
contractions. Swinging and shaking the pelvis forwards and backwards, right and
left sides and circling feels more relaxed and makes it easier to open the
birth canal during labor (Wulandari & Wahyuni, 2019). In his research, he revealed that
there was an effect of using a birthing ball on first-time labor in
primigravida. From the treatment group and the control group there is a
difference of 2.9 hours. The average control group takes 10.15 hours, while the
treatment group takes 7.25 hours. The progress or length of labor as well as
the age of first pregnancy and childbirth among mothers is not the same between
one mother and another. Almost all respondents in this study were 20-35 years
old, but the difference was between the treatment group and the control group
in the length of labor in the first stage. One of the labor factors raised in
this study is pasase and position. In this section and position, the mother is
given treatment by providing therapy using birthing ball to strengthen the
abdominal and waist muscles. In addition, it can reduce pressure on the
abdomen, reduce pressure on the bladder, help the mother relax to relieve
tension which has an impact on reducing the labor pain felt by the mother. The
physical movement that is practiced with pelvic rocking is also beneficial to
increase the pelvic exit by 30%. This facilitates stretching of the perineum
without much pressure and optimizes oxygen flow and blood circulation to the
fetus due to the upright sitting position of the birthing mother.
The
second journal (Fahlevie et al., 2022) states that Birth Ball can affect the
length of the active phase in primigravida due to the application of an upright
position combined with movement on the ball. When respondents use the birth
ball, respondents not only benefit from an upright position that allows gravity
to help lower the fetal head, but also move and increase uterine contractions
to be stronger and more efficient to help lower the fetal head and cervical
dilatation so that the duration of the active phase is faster. Sitting on a
birh ball during labor helps contractions to be more effective as well as
bringing the fetus quickly down the pelvis, the pressure of the fetal head on
the cervix remains constant when the mother is upright so that the cervix can
be dilated more quickly. The pelvic ligament will be more relaxed and the
pelvic plane will be wider with the use of birth ball (Aprilia Yessi, 2020).
With the application of this best practice birth ball, it provides a pleasant
experience for the mother so that tiring and painful labor can be replaced.
The
same results were also obtained in a study conducted by Umi Salamah, Alfi Aulia
Putri (2022), pelvic rocking techniques were also used. the relationship
between the use of birth balls on the length of the first stage of labor, the
highest number of mothers who gave birth normally using birth balls with an
average length of labor of 3 - 8 hours as many as 89 mothers gave birth
(78.8%), and a small number of mothers who experienced long labor (5.3%). Birth
mothers in this study sat on the ball and rocked so that the suppleness and
curvature of the ball could stimulate receptors in the pelvis that are responsible
for releasing endorphins.
Another
advantage of using birthball is that it can increase the opening of the pelvis
by 30%, birh ball works in harmony with gravity which pushes the baby down so
as to speed up the labor process (Elias et al., 2015).
The fourth journal Alexandre Delgadoa,
Tuíra Maiaa, Renato S. Meloa, Andrea Lemos (2019) in a systematic review
conducted using 7 journals as a study obtained results showing the
effectiveness of using birth balls compared to usual care during labor can
reduce pain after 20 to 90 minutes by 1.46 and 1.95 points on the Visual
Analogue Scale, based on the quality of the moderated evidence (Lowe, 1993).
The same results were also obtained in
a study conducted by Umi Salamah, Alfi Aulia Putri (2022), pelvic rocking
techniques were also used. the relationship between the use of birth balls on
the length of the first stage of labor, the highest number of mothers who gave
birth normally using birth balls with an average length of labor of 3 - 8 hours
as many as 89 mothers gave birth (78.8%), and a small number of mothers who
experienced long labor (5.3%). Birth mothers in this study sat on the ball and
rocked so that the suppleness and curvature of the ball could stimulate
receptors in the pelvis that are responsible for releasing endorphins.
Another advantage of using birthball
is that it can increase the opening of the pelvis by 30%, birh ball works in
harmony with gravity which pushes the baby down so as to speed up the labor
process (Leung, Lau, Chan, & Yan, 2010).
The fourth journal Alexandre Delgadoa,
Tuíra Maiaa, Renato S. Meloa, Andrea Lemos (2019) in a systematic review
conducted using 7 journals as a study obtained results showing the
effectiveness of using birth balls compared to usual care during labor can
reduce pain after 20 to 90 minutes by 1.46 and 1.95 points on the Visual
Analogue Scale, based on the quality of the moderated evidence.
The
fifth journal of Morvarid Ghasab Shirazi, Shahnaz Kohan, Firoozeh
Firoozehchian, Elham Ebrahimi (2019) the procedure carried out in his research
was the use of birth ball in pregnant women with a duration of 20 minutes which
was carried out 3 times a week within 6-8 weeks. Based on the results of the
study, birth ball training can significantly increase self-efficacy so that
labor p(Ip, 2005). (Dirgahayu & Rustikayanti, 2022).
ain becomes lower in the group given
this treatment compared to the group that is not. This self-efficacy has a
mediating effect of 30-40% on labor pain (Lowe NK, 1993).
In addition, the use of birth balls
can mobilize the sacroiliac and lumbosacral joints, as well as oblique and
transverse muscle tone so as to help pregnant women manage their birth
according to good posture (Leung, 2013 and Ip WY, 2005). The use of birth ball
can help reduce pain due to contractions, reduce anxiety and shorten the length
of the first stage of labor. The use of birth ball can also help laboring
mothers to make changes in position that can help mothers to go through the
labor process effectively (Dirgahayu & Rustikayanti. 2022).
The same results were also obtained in
the sixth journal Yeung, May Pui Shan, et al (2019) which used the method:
Prospective
KESIMPULAN
Based on the results of the journal search through the
stages of identification, screening, eligbility and including, 6 journals were
obtained that explained the effect of birth ball exercises on the progress of
opening the labor process in laboring mothers. Where all journals mention that
there is an effectiveness of using birth balls in accelerating the length of
kala 1. There are many techniques in the use of birth balls, one of which is
the pelvic rocking technique which can be used by all groups of women where the
technique is done by swinging and shaking the pelvis forward and backward,
right and left sides and making it feel more relaxed and facilitating the
opening of the birth canal during labor.
BIBLIOGRAFI
Andini, Ayu. (2020). Angka Kematian Ibu Di Indonesia
Masih Jauh Dari Target Sdgs. Tersedia Dari Lokadata. Id› Artikel›
Angka-Kematian-Ibu-Di-Indonesia. Diakses Pada Tanggal, 12.
Anuhgera,
Diah Evawanna, Ritonga, Nikmah Jalilah, Sitorus, Riris, & Simarmata, Juni
Mariati. (2021). Penerapan Birth Ball Dengan Teknik Pelvic Rocking Terhadap
Lama Persalinan Pada Kala I Fase Aktif. Jurnal Keperawatan Dan Fisioterapi
(Jkf), 4(1), 70–76.
Dirgahayu,
Inggrid, & Rustikayanti, Nety. (2022). Birth Ball Exercises Dalam
Menurunkan Intensitas Nyeri Persalinan Kala I: Literature Review. Jurnal
Keperawatan, 14(1), 1–10.
Elias,
Ana Catarina Araújo, Ricci, Marcos Desidério, Rodriguez, Lórgio Henrique Diaz,
Pinto, Stela Duarte, Giglio, Joel Sales, & Baracat, Edmund Chada. (2015).
The Biopsychosocial Spiritual Model Applied To The Treatment Of Women With
Breast Cancer, Through Rime Intervention (Relaxation, Mental Images,
Spirituality). Complementary Therapies In Clinical Practice, 21(1),
1–6.
Fahlevie,
Rizah, Anggraini, Helni, & Yunola, Satra. (2022). The Effectiveness Of
Birth Ball On The Long Time Of Active Phase I In Primigravida In Pmb Az-Zahwa
Muara Enim In 2021. Science Midwifery, 10(2), 825–828.
Ip,
Wanyim. (2005). The Effect Of A Theory-Based Intervention On Promoting
Self-Efficacy For Childbirth Among Pregnant Women In Hong Kong. The Chinese
University Of Hong Kong (Hong Kong).
Leung,
N. Y., Lau, A. C., Chan, K. K., & Yan, W. W. (2010). Clinical Characteristics
And Outcomes Of Obstetric Patients Admitted To The Intensive Care Unit: A
10-Year Retrospective Review. Hong Kong Med J, 16(1), 18–25.
Lowe,
Nancy K. (1993). Maternal Confidence For Labor: Development Of The Childbirth
Self‐Efficacy Inventory. Research In Nursing & Health, 16(2),
141–149.
Mu’alimah,
Miftakhul, Saidah, Halimatus, Wigati, Putri Wahyu, Sutrisni, Sutrisni,
Kartikasari, Dewi, & Sunaningsih, Sunaningsih. (2022). Pemberdayaan Ibu
Hamil Dengan Menerapkan Prenatal Gentle Yoga Menuju Kehamilan Sehat Pada Ibu
Hamil Trimester Ii Dan Iii. Journal Of Community Engagement In Health, 5(1),
38–41.
Mu’alimah,
Miftakhul, & Wigati, Putri Wahyu. (2022). The Effect Of The Use Of Birthing
Ball On The Progress Of First Stage Childbirth On Primigravida. Journal For
Quality In Public Health, 5(2), 626–631.
Mutoharoh,
Siti, Indrayani, Eni, & Kusumastuti, K. (2020). Pengaruh Latihan Birthball
Terhadap Proses Persalinan. Jurnal Ilmiah Kesehatan, 13(1).
Pertasari,
Ratu Miki Yulieti. (2022). Efektifitas Birth Ball Terhadap Kemajuan Persalinan
Pada Ibu Bersalin Di Klinik Permata Bunda Kota Serang. Journal Of Midwifery,
10(1), 77–82.
Shirazi,
Morvarid Ghasab, Kohan, Shahnaz, Firoozehchian, Firoozeh, & Ebrahimi,
Elham. (2019). Experience Of Childbirth With Birth Ball: A Randomized
Controlled Trial. International Journal Of Women’s Health And Reproduction
Sciences, 7(3), 301–305.
Wigati,
Putri Wahyu, & Mualimah, Miftakhul. (2021). Pengaruh Pendidikan Kesehatan
Melalui Media Sosial Terhadap Pengetahuan Ibu Nifas Tentang Teknik Menyusui
Pada Masa Pandemi Covid 19 Di Wilayah Kerja Puskesmas Puncu Kabupaten Kediri. Judika
(Jurnal Nusantara Medika), 5(2), 1–7.
Wulandari,
C. L., & Wahyuni, S. (2019). Efektivitas Pelvic Rocking Exercise Pada Ibu
Bersalin Kala I Terhadap Kemajuan Persalinan Dan Lama Persalinan. Semarang:
Ef Press Digimedia.