Volume
5, No. 4 April, 2024
p
ISSN 2723-6927-e ISSN 2723-4339
The Effectiveness Of Spiritual Emotional Freedom Technique In
Reducing The Incidence Of Postpartum Blues In Pregnant Women
Rahma
Zakia Mubarok1, Irma Finuria Mustikawati2, Paramita
Septianawati3, Glorio Immanuel4
1,2,3,4 Faculty
of Medicine, University of Muhammadiyah Purwokerto, Central Java, Indonesia
Email: rahmazakiamubarok@gmail.com1, irmafinurinamustikawati@ump.ac.id2, paramitaseptianawati@ump.ac.id3, glo_rio@yahoo.com4
ABSTRACT
Despite the joy of being pregnant, some
mothers experience anxiety and depression after giving birth. Blues Depression
and anxiety throughout pregnancy and after have a significant negative
influence on pregnant women's mental health. This research reviewed the
available literature. Electronic databases, including Pubmed, Google Scholar,
and ProQuest, were used for the searches. Journals containing the terms
"Spiritual Emotional Freedom Technique (SEFT)," "Postpartum
Blues," "Pregnant Women," and "Pregnancy" were found
in the first search. The study's findings indicate that spiritual practices
like dhikr and mutual Al-Qur'an, as well as faith-based treatment and spiritual
beliefs, have the ability to lessen pregnant women's anxiety and despair. This study intends to find
out if Spiritual EFT could be a useful option for reducing symptoms of
postpartum blues, a psychological illness that can impact a woman's emotional
health after childbirth. The findings
of the study indicate that using this therapy can significantly improve the
mental health of expectant mothers.
Keywords:
Spiritual
Emotional Freedom Technique, Postpartum Blues, Depression, Pregnant Women
INTRODUCTION
Happiness can be affected by pregnancy, especially for mothers. When a
woman finds out that she is pregnant for the first time, she often feels both
excitement and anxiety (Yagmur & Oltuluoglu, 2021). In France, depression affects 11.8% of pregnant women and anxiety
affects 13.2% of them. 7.9% of mothers who experienced anxiety were
primigravida. Anxiety afflicts 373,000,000 pregnant women in Indonesia or 28.7%
of all pregnant women (Viandika & Septiasari, 2021).
Depression is one type of mood condition that has an impact on a person's
personality. It is also a term for emotions such as melancholy, depression,
aggravation, dissatisfaction, and suffering. Meanwhile, postpartum depression
is one disorder that can attack women after giving birth. No one expected to
experience this because, in general, women who are pregnant, especially those
who are pregnant for the first time, are certainly waiting for the birth of
their child (Zaręba, Banasiewicz, Rozenek,
Wójtowicz, & Jakiel, 2020).
Based on research conducted in East Java, 12.9% of pregnant women
experience mild anxiety, 31.4% experience severe anxiety, and the rest are
classified as normal (Zainiyah & Susanti, 2020). Data shows that pregnant women still experience significant levels of
anxiety. Anxiety can be affected by age, gender, personality type, and physical
health. Environmental and socio-cultural variables may play a role (Anggraini & Handayani, 2021). Age, education level, and family support level are just some of the
factors that may contribute to pregnancy anxiety (Yu, Qiu, Liu, Cui, & Wu, 2020). In addition, the mother and fetus are also affected by this concern.
According to (McNestry, Killeen, Crowley, &
McAuliffe, 2023), .
The term "postpartum depression" is also used to refer to
patients who experience various emotional disorders that develop after
childbirth, specifically certain depressive disorders that affect 17.7% of all
women worldwide and are experienced by 10-15% of women initially. year after
childbirth (Hahn-Holbrook, Cornwell-Hinrichs, &
Anaya, 2018). In Indonesia, between 50
and 70 percent of women experience this condition, which has a range of
postpartum depression rates between 5 to more than 25 percent (Renata & Agus, 2021).
Previous research found a number of risk factors for postpartum depression,
including prenatal depression, anxiety, stressful life events, and variables
associated with postpartum depression within the first year of labor, such as
economic disparities (Norhayati, Hazlina, Asrenee, &
Emilin, 2015). According to (Wisner, Chambers, & Sit, 2006), postpartum depression is a serious public health problem. As a result,
mothers may experience severe negative impacts, which will make it difficult
for them to balance parenting, taking care of the house, and fulfilling their
work obligations. In addition, postpartum depression in the mother can have a
serious impact on the child's behavior as well as his physical, emotional, and
cognitive growth (Manurung & Setyowati, 2021).
Because many still consider mental problems normal, such as maternal
instincts and protective attitudes towards newborns, postpartum blues are
considered an iceberg event that is difficult to uncover. Pay attention to the
psychological signs experienced by pregnant women after giving birth. Because
psychotherapy has no adverse effects on the mother or fetus and does not cause
allergic reactions or medication, psychotherapy is essential for managing
stress and anxiety. Supportive psychotherapy, re-education psychotherapy,
reconstructive psychotherapy, cognitive psychotherapy, psychodynamic
psychotherapy, behavioral psychotherapy, family psychotherapy, psycho-religious
therapy, and relaxation techniques are some examples of psychotherapeutic
techniques. Interventions, etc., will change based on the needs of the person
and his or her family (Liu & Yang, 2021).
Energy psychology is a new subfield of psychology that includes SEFT.
Using the body's energy system to change mental states, emotions, and behavior
is the foundation of energy psychology. Various emotional illnesses, including
sadness, stress, and anxiety, are affected by chemical imbalances in the body. The
body's energy disorders may strongly influence the appearance of emotional
disorders, and changes in the body's energy system can alter brain chemistry,
which in turn can alter the emotional state. This is supported by a large
amount of scientific research (Zainuddin, 2014).
Previous research has shown that nonpharmacological therapy can also help
pregnant women feel more comfortable, calm, and relaxed while reducing anxiety
levels (Susilowati, Pramana, & Muis, 2019). Pregnant women may also feel better and relax when touch freedom
techniques are added. This is in line with previous research (Niko, 2018), which showed that recollection therapy can reduce stress levels. The
results further showed that the use of Qur'anic murotal therapy helped relieve
pregnancy-related anxiety, and such anxiety could be managed with the Spiritual
Emotional Freedom Technique (Wisuda, bin Sansuwito, & Suraya,
2024).
The purpose of this study was to evaluate how well spiritual emotional
liberation strategies work in preventing postpartum blues in pregnant women.
The aim of this study was to equip pregnant women with a broader
knowledge of the Spiritual Emotional Freedom Technique (EFT) as a tool that can
help them experience the Postpartum Blues less often. This study intends to
find out if Spiritual EFT could be a useful option for reducing symptoms of
postpartum blues, a psychological illness that can impact a woman's emotional
health after childbirth.
Results and Discussions
Spiritual Emotional Freedom
Technique (EFT)
EFT therapy is a type of psychotherapy that combines psychology,
spirituality, and prayer (Putranti, 2021). EFT is based on the idea that certain places in the body's twelve
energy meridians, sometimes called energy channels, have a major impact on
certain health disorders. A body that significantly affects our health. Five
principles to follow when using EFT: assurance, sincerity, surrender, and
gratitude. The five things we need to do in therapy are Set-up, Tune In,
Tapping, and Reflect (Shava, 2023).
The psychological therapy approach that evolved from EFT is called SEFT.
Energy psychology is the main theory that is the fundamental foundation of SEFT
as a technique (Zainuddin, 2014). Theoretically, energy psychology is based on
acupuncture theory but applies a needleless approach (Gallo, 2017). Energy psychology theory has the same assumption as acupuncture theory,
namely that everyone has an energy system that controls all physical and
psychological processes. The energy system consists of 365 meridian pathways of
the body that function as a space for the flow of chi, chakras, or acupoints
that function as centers for energy creation and supply energy to the cells of
the human body, as well as life force, or commonly done by Chinese healers. Referred
to as Chi (Gallo, 2017).
Based on various acupuncture studies, including (Church, De Asis, & Brooks, 2012) found that acupuncture points can send signals directly to the amygdala
region of the limbic system and other brain regions that process fear.
According to this theory, (Widodo, Silitonga, & Ali, 2020) found that acupuncture can deactivate the blood of the limbic system and
neocortex in its investigation. Therefore, compared to psychotherapy and
relaxation, (Church et al., 2012) found that EFT practices can lower cortisol levels significantly. This
decrease in cortisol levels is strongly associated with decreased signs and
symptoms of anxiety, depression, and other psychological illnesses. EFT has a
significant impact on fear-related brain waves.
Postpartum Blues
According to (Olii et al., 2023), postpartum blues are episodes of low mood and moderate depressive
symptoms that are temporary and limited. In affective domains such as feelings,
behaviors, or thoughts, postpartum blues syndrome is defined as various changes
(Manurung & Setyowati, 2021). Etiology Hormonal changes are one of the main causes of postpartum mood
swings, while their pathogenesis remains largely unclear. After childbirth,
estrogen, progesterone, and prolactin levels usually decrease dramatically (Olii et al., 2023).
One of the causes of postpartum blues, according to (Dowlati & Meyer, 2021), is:
1.
When hormonal changes occur rapidly.
2.
Unexpected discomfort, such as swollen breasts
and pain during childbirth.
3.
Concerns that arise after leaving the hospital
or maternity clinic and returning home.
4.
Breastfeed.
5.
The way you sleep has
changed.
Clinical signs and symptoms: Sadness,
sobbing, fatigue, impatience, anxiety, lack of sleep, lack of focus, erratic
mood, and changes in appetite are signs of postpartum depression. These
symptoms often appear two to three days after delivery, peak in the following
days, and disappear on their own two weeks after first appearing (Olii et al., 2023).
The Spiritual Connection
of Emotional Freedom Techniques to Postpartum Blues Events
In order to reduce stress hormones, listening to the holy verse of the
Qur'an can activate endorphins and trigger delta waves. This arrangement can
make the listener feel comfortable and relaxed, which will have a positive
impact on his mind and heart as well as his relaxed, serene, and serene
physical state. By lowering blood pressure, respiratory rate, heart rate, and
brainwave activity, listening to the Murottal Quran can reduce feelings of
fear, anxiety, and stress and improve body biochemistry (Wisuda et al., 2024).
Dhikr has spiritual and religious components that can increase optimism
and self-confidence while boosting immunity and inner strength. Dhikr also
strengthens one's desire to achieve goals and inspires feelings of satisfaction
(Fahrizal & Saputri, 2023). It also brings a person closer to God, makes them feel as if they are
in His care, and cultivates serenity and peace in their soul.
Symptoms of postpartum blues, according to (Olii et al., 2023), include melancholy, crying, fatigue, impatience, anxiety, poor sleep
quality, and erratic mood. Mothers will feel relaxed, calm, and serene after
receiving murottaI AI-Qur'an and dhikr therapy, which will reduce postpartum
blues symptoms in mothers.
Figure 1. The Spiritual
Relationship of Emotional Freedom Technique to Postpartum Blues Events (Kumala,
Kusprayogi and Nashori, 2017)
Systematic Review
A systematic review is a research technique for finding, assessing, and
interpreting all research findings related to a particular research question,
subject, or problematic event (Kitchenham, 2004). Primary research includes
individual studies, and secondary research includes systematic reviews. A
systematic review will be helpful in combining diverse, relevant research
findings, resulting in more thorough and impartial
information provided to policymakers (Siswanto, 2010).
Figure 2. The Relationship
between Research and Policy in the Perspective of Utilizing
A systematic review, as the name suggests, is a type of research
methodology that presents more thorough and impartial information by condensing
key research findings. Meta-analysis is one method that combines quantitative
methodology. An additional method of synthesis of results is a qualitative
approach. In other words, meta-analysis is the quantitative component of the
systematic review procedure (Siswanto, 2010).
A. Method
This research strategy uses qualitative methods. The methods used include
meta-analysis and literature review. A method called meta-analysis is used to
compile research findings from previous studies related to the same research
question. Using meta-analyses, researchers can evaluate all available data, identify
emerging trends from the findings of this study, and reach stronger conclusions
compared to a single study (Mohan et al., 2022).
In conducting a meta-analysis, there are several analysis processes that
must be carried out, including:
1.
Set criteria for research inclusion and
disqualification. These scientists set criteria for selecting studies for
analysis. This criterion takes into account the type of study, year of
publication, language, and other elements.
2.
These are the inclusion requirements for the
study:
a. Use English or Indonesian;
b. Not limited to the year of study.
c. The purpose of this study is to determine the effectiveness of the
spiritual, emotional freedom technique in reducing the incidence of postpartum
blues in pregnant women.
The exclusion
criteria for this study are as follows:
a.
Research is conducted in languages other than
Indonesian or English
b.
Research that does not touch on the
effectiveness of spiritual emotional freedom techniques in reducing the
incidence of postpartum blues in pregnant women.
1.
Literature search
Researchers use
specific inclusion and exclusion criteria to guide their literature search.
Electronic databases such as Pubmed, Google Scholar, and ProQuest can be used
for searches. The initial search yielded journals using the search terms
"Spiritual Emotional Freedom Technique (SEFT)," "Postpartum
Blues," "Pregnant," and "Pregnancy."
2.
Selection Study
The researchers
conducted a study search using predetermined inclusion and exclusion criteria
after assessing the literature. Studies that meet inclusion requirements are
added to the analysis.
3.
Data extraction
Researchers selected related data from each selected study. The data collected may consist of things like research findings, research factors, sample size, etc.
4.
Data analysis
The results of
the collected studies are now combined using statistical analysis by the
researchers. The analysis to be carried out may include heterogeneity tests,
publication bias tests, meta-analyses of random effects or fixed effects, etc.
5.
Interpretation of results
Researchers hid the results of the combined study after data analysis. The correlation between the variables studied was then further inferred from these findings.
Systematic Review Analysis
The table presented showed that pregnant women who underwent SEFT therapy
experienced a decrease in anxiety. First, research with a quasi-experimental
approach conducted by (Shava,
2023) revealed that dhikr and SEFT treatment is effective in reducing anxiety
in III-trimester pregnant women. With a relatively low p-value, the results of
Wilcoxon and Mann-Whitney's statistical test show a significant difference.
This suggests that both medications may be useful options for dealing with
anxiety in pregnant women.
In addition, (Zukhruf & Itryah, 2023) research using observation, conversation, and question-and-answer
techniques shows that many pregnant women do not know about postpartum blues
and how to overcome these problems after giving birth. However, pregnant women
understand this issue better after receiving Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT)
counseling and related knowledge. This underscores the need to educate
expectant mothers about mental health issues during pregnancy and postpartum.
Furthermore, research by (Jalal,
Roya, & Masoumeh, 2023) showed that the SMARTER intervention succeeded in reducing depression
rates in pregnant women. The results of statistical analysis showed that the
intervention group and the control group differed significantly. Based on these
findings, additional treatment should be offered in obstetric services to help
pregnant women who are depressed. This is especially true for midwives.
Remembrance psychoeducation, according to (Rofacky
& Aini, 2015), can help reduce the incidence of postpartum depression. To combat
postpartum depression, it is recommended that midwives incorporate remembrance
readings into their standard treatment.
In addition, (Liang
et al., 2021)) showed that the stress level of type II diabetes patients can be
lowered with the use of dhikr treatment. The findings of this study suggest
that, for some groups, dhikr relaxation may be an effective treatment
alternative for managing stress.
According to (Ulya,
Rahayu, & Sulistyono, 2023) research with quasi-experimental methodology, Qur'anic marital therapy
is beneficial in reducing anxiety in third-trimester pregnant women. These
findings suggest that Qur'anic murottal therapy may be a useful substitute for
conventional treatment of pregnancy-related anxiety.
According to (Rizki,
Masruroh, & Rahayu, 2023), every pregnant participant in her study knew how to use SEFT to reduce
anxiety before giving birth and was able to do so. This suggests that pregnant
women may perceive SEFT as an approach that is easy to understand and use.
A literature review conducted by (Susilowati
et al., 2019) concluded that anxiety in pregnant women can be influenced by various
variables and treated with various therapies, including relaxation, music
therapy, and supportive group therapy. The findings of this analysis provide a
complete picture of the various strategies available to cope with anxiety in
pregnant women.
Overall, the study's findings highlight the importance of focusing on
pregnant women's mental health and offering a range of therapies that can help
address anxiety and depression issues. Because pregnant women undergo
counseling to help them cope with their worries, the physiological effects of
anxiety may go away on their own. But this takes much time because everyone's
coping style might affect how quickly they adjust. Age may also contribute to
decreased anxiety in pregnant women receiving SEFT therapy; As they get older,
their thought processes become more mature.
As we get older, a person will be wiser in facing challenges, both those
inside his own head and those outside his environment. Because immature
thinking interferes with a person's ability to face or deal with difficulties, young
individuals are more vulnerable to worry.
This is supported by research by (Shava, 2023) which found that the purpose of the series of SEFT procedures carried
out is to ensure the body's energy flow is directed in the right direction
through psychological neutralization or psychological resistance, which is
assisted by prayer for submission. Se-tup performs two tasks. They first
surrender themselves to God and willingly accept suffering. As a result, the
spiritual component of SEFT treatment delivered through prayer sentences can
improve one's mood. Chest compressions in the afternoon spot area are the
second setup stage.
Adjusting to the discomfort you feel is the next stage of adjustment.
Then concentrate on suffering while surrendering to God's will. Light tapping
at 18 locations of the body is the last tapping technique. Tapping will stimulate
the active electrical cells because it stimulates the active nuclei of the
electrical cells. Transduction signals are generated when the interception site
is stimulated by biological activity. Physiologically, tapping can trigger the
release of endorphins from the pituitary gland. By calming and eliciting
emotions of pleasure, this hormone helps reduce anxiety.
A person's conception of health will depend on his spiritual beliefs,
specifically his adherence to religious doctrines. This will have an impact on
the belief that everything that happens is the result of the will of God
Almighty, which must be accepted and thanked in order to reduce feelings of
hopelessness and insecurity and increase spiritual motivation ((Liu & Yang, 2021); (Rusner, Berg, & Begley, 2016)). Positive energy in the form of affirmations from the patient's
personal touches will make the patient feel calmer and ready to face the
situation faced after childbirth (Rofacky & Aini, 2015). This is done by providing therapy to patients to provide psychological
energy by prioritizing or utilizing what is in the human body itself so that
the strength in the patient will be more excited.
CONCLUSION
Based on the discussion above, it can be concluded that treatment based
on religion and spiritual beliefs, including SEFT therapy and various spiritual
remedies such as dhikr and Qur'an murottal, can help reduce anxiety and
depression in pregnant women. Research findings show that the use of this
therapy can significantly improve the mental health of pregnant women. In
addition, a pregnant woman's level of anxiety and anguish may be influenced by
things like age, personal coping mechanisms, and spiritual beliefs.
REFERENCES
Anggraini, Fritria Dwi,
& Handayani, Nanik. (2021). The Effect of Education on Self Efficacy and
Anxiety levels Before Childbirth During the Covid-19 Pandemic in Third
Trimester Pregnant. STRADA Jurnal Ilmiah Kesehatan, 10(1),
213–218.
Church, Dawson, De Asis, Midanelle A., & Brooks, Audrey J. (2012).
Brief group intervention using emotional freedom techniques for depression in
college students: a randomized controlled trial. Depression Research and Treatment,
2012.
Dowlati, Yekta, & Meyer, Jeffrey H. (2021). Promising leads and
pitfalls: a review of dietary supplements and hormone treatments to prevent
postpartum blues and postpartum depression. Archives of Women’s Mental
Health, 24(3), 381–389.
Fahrizal, Yanuar, & Saputri, Reny Nur. (2023). Effect Of
Psycho-Religious Group Therapy On Hallucination In Schizophrenia Patient. Medisains,
21(1), 13.
Gallo, F. P. (2017). The judge’s trauma mindful energy psychology for
trauma, phobia, depression, and clarifying needs© 2017. MOJ Public Health,
5(4), 134–136.
Hahn-Holbrook, Jennifer, Cornwell-Hinrichs, Taylor, & Anaya, Itzel.
(2018). Economic and health predictors of national postpartum depression
prevalence: a systematic review, meta-analysis, and meta-regression of 291
studies from 56 countries. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 8, 301051.
Jalal, Rezaei, Roya, Azouji, & Masoumeh, ZakeriMoghadam. (2023). The
effect of self-care education with smart phone applications on the severity of
mucositis and infection after stem cell transplantation in leukemia patients.
Liang, Lizhen, Feng, Ling, Zheng, Xiaoming, Wu, Ying, Zhang, Chunhua,
& Li, Jingjing. (2021). Effect of dialectical behavior group therapy on the
anxiety and depression of medical students under the normalization of epidemic
prevention and control for the COVID-19 epidemic: a randomized study. Annals
of Palliative Medicine, 10(10), 105910599.
Liu, Hongling, & Yang, Yang. (2021). Effects of a psychological
nursing intervention on prevention of anxiety and depression in the postpartum
period: a randomized controlled trial. Annals of General Psychiatry, 20,
1–7.
Manurung, Suryani, & Setyowati, S. (2021). Development and validation
of the maternal blues scale through bonding attachments in predicting
postpartum blues. Malaysian Family Physician: The Official Journal of the
Academy of Family Physicians of Malaysia, 16(1), 64.
McNestry, Catherine, Killeen, Sarah L., Crowley, Rachel K., &
McAuliffe, Fionnuala M. (2023). Pregnancy complications and later life women’s
health. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica, 102(5),
523–531.
Mohan, P., Lemoine, J., Trotter, C., Rakova, I., Billings, P., Peacock,
S., Kao, C‐Y, Wang, Y., Xia, F., & Eng, C. M. (2022). Clinical
experience with non‐invasive prenatal screening for single‐gene
disorders. Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology, 59(1),
33–39.
Niko, Puti Febrina. (2018). The effect of dhikr therapy to reduce anxiety
in pregnant women. Islamic Journal, 1(1).
Norhayati, M. N., Hazlina, N. H. Nik, Asrenee, A. R., & Emilin, W. M.
A. Wan. (2015). Magnitude and risk factors for postpartum symptoms: a
literature review. Journal of Affective Disorders, 175, 34–52.
Olii, Nancy, Salman, Salman, Abdul, Nurnaningsih Ali, Astuti, Siti Choirul
Dwi, Porouw, Hasnawatty Surya, Mohamad, Selvi, Claudia, Juli Gladis, &
Astuti, Eka Rati. (2023). Literature Riview: Determinants of Postpartum Blues. Jurnal
Aisyah: Jurnal Ilmu Kesehatan, 8(S1), 57–62.
Putranti, Anggraini Dwi. (2021). Seft (Spiritual Emotional Freedom
Technique) untuk Menurunkan Kecemasan Ibu Hamil Trimester III. Jurnal
Psikologi, 17(2), 53–62.
Renata, Brigita, & Agus, Dharmady. (2021). Association of husband
support and postpartum blues in postpartum women. Indonesian Journal of
Obstetrics and Gynecology, 140–143.
Rizki, Lailatul Khusnul, Masruroh, Nur, & Rahayu, Esty Puji. (2023).
Effects of self-affirmation and positive visualization therapy for anxiety in
3rd-trimester pregnant women during the pandemic. Bali Medical Journal, 12(3),
2797–2800.
Rofacky, H. F., & Aini, F. (2015). Effects of Spiritual Therapy on
Emotional Freedom Technique (SEFT) Against Blood Pressure Patients with
Hypertension. Nursing Journal Sudirman, 10(1), 41–52.
Rusner, Marie, Berg, Marie, & Begley, Cecily. (2016). Bipolar disorder
in pregnancy and childbirth: a systematic review of outcomes. BMC Pregnancy
and Childbirth, 16, 1–18.
Shava, Syahputra. (2023). Pengaruh Terapi Spiritual Emotional Freedom
Technique (Seft) Terhadap Kecemasan Pada Ibu Hamil Trimester Iii (Studi di Poli
Kandungan RSU Anna Medika Madura). STIKES NGUDIA HUSADA MADURA.
Siswanto, Siswanto. (2010). Systematic review sebagai metode penelitian
untuk mensintesis hasil-hasil penelitian (sebuah pengantar). Buletin
Penelitian Sistem Kesehatan, 13(4), 21312.
Susilowati, Tri, Pramana, Noor, & Muis, Siti Fatimah. (2019).
Intervensi Non Farmakologi Terhadap Kecemasan Pada Primigravida. Jurnal
Ilmiah Permas: Jurnal Ilmiah STIKES Kendal, 9(3), 181–186.
Ulya, Nia Afifatul, Rahayu, Heni Setyowati Esti, & Sulistyono, Dwi.
(2023). The Effect of Al-Qur’an Murottal Therapy on Anxiety in Third Trimester
Pregnant Women: Study Literature Reviews. 4th Borobudur International
Symposium on Humanities and Social Science 2022 (BIS-HSS 2022), 1033–1042.
Atlantis Press.
Viandika, Nurya, & Septiasari, Ratih Mega. (2021). Anxiety in pregnant
women during pandemic COVID-19. Jurnal Keperawatan Jiwa (JKJ): Persatuan
Perawat Nasional Indonesia, 9(1), 135–142.
Widodo, Djoko Setyo, Silitonga, P., & Ali, Hapzi. (2020). The
Influence of Good Governance, Culture, and Performance in Increasing Public
Satisfaction and Implication to Public Trust: Study in Indonesian Government. Talent
Development & Excellence, 12(2).
Wisner, Katherine L., Chambers, Christina, & Sit, Dorothy K. Y.
(2006). Postpartum depression: a major public health problem. Jama, 296(21),
2616–2618.
Wisuda, Aris Citra, bin Sansuwito, Tukimin, & Suraya, Citra. (2024).
Islamic Spiritual Care with Murottal for Reducing Anxiety and Depression in
Coronary Heart Disease Patients: A Comprehensive Systematic Review. Public
Health of Indonesia, 10(1), 61–72.
Yagmur, Yurdagul, & Oltuluoglu, Hatice. (2021). Emotions and thoughts
of individuals who have become a father for the first time: A qualitative
research. International Journal of Caring Sciences, 14(1),
147–157.
Yu, Mingli, Qiu, Tian, Liu, Chunli, Cui, Qi, & Wu, Hui. (2020). The
mediating role of perceived social support between anxiety symptoms and life
satisfaction in pregnant women: a cross-sectional study. Health and Quality
of Life Outcomes, 18, 1–8.
Zainiyah, Zakkiyatus, & Susanti, Eny. (2020). Anxiety in pregnant
women during coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic in East Java, Indonesia. Majalah
Kedokteran Bandung, 52(3), 149–153.
Zainuddin, A. F. (2014). SEFT Total Solution (Healing Happiness Success
Greatness). Jakarta: Afzan Publishing.
Zaręba, Kornelia, Banasiewicz, Jolanta, Rozenek, Hanna, Wójtowicz,
Stanisław, & Jakiel, Grzegorz. (2020). Peripartum predictors of the
risk of postpartum depressive disorder: Results of a case-control study. International
Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(23), 8726.
Zukhruf, Meita Robbiatul, & Itryah, Itryah. (2023). Penyuluhan
Pecegahan Postpartum Blues Menggunakan Terapi Emotional Freedom Technique
(EFT). Jurnal Abdimas Bina Bangsa, 4(1), 500–505.
Copyright Holder: Rahma Zakia Mubarok, Irma Finuria Mustikawati,
Paramita Septianawati, Glorio Immanuel (2024) |
First
Publication Right: Jurnal Health Sains |
This article is licensed under: |